Review: Tatiana and Alexander by Paullina Simons

From June, 2003

This is the long-anticipated sequel to The Bronze Horseman…and very worth the wait!

T&A is rough going, though. By this I mean emotionally discomforting. Now, I was in the middle of this book when the United States went to war in Iraq, and I was hearing reports of soldiers being abducted, bringing Alexander’s POW experience to vivid life. That was when I had to put the book down and wait until the initial stages of the war were complete. How this coincidence turned my stomach! The fighting, the torture, interrogation, death, pain of separation, the unbearable suspense–and I’m not at all saying anything negative about the book itself. In fact, this is quite a compliment. That it provoked such an intense reaction,  it was REALISTIC and hard-hitting, and what a feat that is for a novel.

It was fascinating reading Alexander’s point of view: the first half of the book was Alexander reliving his childhood, recounting how he met Tatiana, and exploring his love for her and the month spent alone together at Lazarevo. Introspective and inviting, the same events were explored from quite a different point of view– the view of a volatile and tortured man. The main focus later in the novel is his experience as a POW. Harrowing and poignant, it kept me on the edge of my seat.  The story was not just Alexander’s, however–Tatiana narrowly escapes the war-torn Stalinist Soviet Union to America at the age of 18 and pregnant, believing herself a widow. How she copes in a foreign land, grieving and not knowing what to believe, and desperately grasping for hope is her narrative, just as heartbreaking and powerful as Alexander’s trials.

The story is a romantic as the first telling but not quite as perfect as its prequel. Occasionally, the plot slowed down to a snail’s pace and there was a bit too much explicit sex even for my taste! It bordered on pornographic at times, but when you think about whose point of view this comes from, it does fit. Alexander was a highly physical human being, expressing his emotions on a sexual level and this part of him came out loud and clear. I wonder if this aspect may have been the reason the a U.S. publisher waited so long to pick it up….(I ordered the book from the UK since I couldn’t wait!)

The story of these ardent lovers is, I believe, based on the lives of Simon’s grandparents. Only inspiration from real life can be this affecting, in my humble opinion. Life is stranger than fiction!

This book is fantastic at the end of it all. Not as perfectly crafted as its predecessor, it is still legions above most fiction out there today.

Tatiana and Alexander

Paullina Simons

Flamingo Press, 2003

564 pp

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: